If he was in HEEEEEEEEAVEEEEEEEEN, then he needs to go find an angsty vampire to make out with. Cue Lenore? (Ohhh, the BtVS crossovers CONTINUE.)

Oh my GOD, the musical. And the boys would have to SING. And maybe BOBBY. And Dean sings REO Speedwagon! And Sam and Dean serenade each other. Yes. *nods* This is the way it would be.

Seriously, though - it must be kind of a bitch for the writers right now, because there are so many things they *can't say* because it was already done on Buffy and everyone remembers!